Page 1 of 2

Bionicpup only boots to console (Solved)

Posted: Sat 14 Mar 2020, 10:04
by bambuko
I have installed bionicpup 64 on usb flash stick.
Works fine with my laptop, but when I try to use it with my desktop it I end up at console without X running.
I suspect it is to do with GPU?
It is: GeForce GTX 1650 SUPER StormX 4GB Graphics Card
My attempts to play with xorgwizard didn't make any difference.
Any suggestions please?

Posted: Sat 14 Mar 2020, 12:08
by Mike Walsh
Hi, bambuko.
bambuko wrote:I have installed bionicpup 64 on usb flash stick.
Works fine with my laptop, but when I try to use it with my desktop it I end up at console without X running.
I suspect it is to do with GPU?
It is: GeForce GTX 1650 SUPER StormX 4GB Graphics Card.
Huh. You and me both, mate.

I've recently purchased a GeForce GT710 (the one with the 'passive' heatsink; no fan), and am also having issues with Bionicpup64. If I have the card installed (just using the kernel's 'nouveau' driver), everything runs fine, except for the fact that I always end up with a weird external IP address, and have no internet.....until I reset the router, and re-connect, and then DNS/DHCP work correctly.

Your issue obviously sounds to be related to the nouveau driver, too.....though your card is a bit more of a 'beast' than mine!

You might have to try using the NVidia driver, I suspect, though whether that would fix the issue is anybody's guess. For now, that's about the only thing I can think of to suggest.

In my case, if I remove the GPU and allow the system to use the Pentium G5400's 'on-die' GPU (using the Intel kernel driver), everything's tickety-boo, and functions as it should do.....

You could, perhaps, also consider a kernel-swap. I know rockedge has compiled a number of alternative kernels, some of which, by all accounts, work very well. Maybe it's the version of the nouveau driver in Bionic64's default kernel that's at the root of the issue? Just a thought.....

All:- Anybody else having 'nouveau' issues with Bionic64.....or is it just bambuko and me?


Mike. :wink:

Posted: Sat 14 Mar 2020, 14:08
by nic007
Revert to an older computer and Puppy. :wink:

Posted: Sat 14 Mar 2020, 14:25
by Mike Walsh
nic007 wrote:Revert to an older computer and Puppy. :wink:
I'm not entirely certain that's going to be an option with this particular 'use-case', Nic. I distinctly remember from a post of his some while back that bambuko runs a highly-customized set-up with pNp 'hot-swappable' hard drives.

(*shrug*)

Unless, of course, this is a more conventional machine.....


Mike. :)

Posted: Sat 14 Mar 2020, 14:35
by bambuko
Yes, hot swappable drives - it's me :P
Still works perfectly well afaic (win10, win7 and various shades of puppy with "mechanical" multiboot)


found the driver for my card:
https://nvidiageforcedrivers.com/nvidia ... for-linux/
(which gives NVIDIA-Linux-x86_64-430.26.run)
or here:
https://www.nvidia.com/Download/index.aspx
(which gives NVIDIA-Linux-x86_64-440.64.run)
I guess the latter should be better...

just need to learn how to update the kernel with this driver (or something like this... bit vague in this department)

Off to my DuckDuckGo to search for an answer

Posted: Sat 14 Mar 2020, 15:22
by nic007
Tongue in the cheek guys. Hope you get things sorted.

Posted: Sat 14 Mar 2020, 15:27
by bambuko
well...
there is this (which I am trying to grasp at the moment):
http://murga-linux.com/puppy/viewtopic.php?p=974663
and
http://www.murga-linux.com/puppy/viewtopic.php?t=72405

Posted: Sat 14 Mar 2020, 16:03
by foxpup
You can try the nvidia-440... driver pet from QuickSetup
or from http://distro.ibiblio.org/puppylinux/pe ... -bionic64/

(This is a good place to find out which driver you have to use for your nvidia card:
https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/drivers/unix/)

Posted: Sat 14 Mar 2020, 16:56
by bambuko
I can't try nvidia-440 driver because I cannot get Puppy started on the PC that is the problem (i.e. X doesn't start, so I don't get beyond boot menus)
and trying to do it on my laptop ends up in failure :(

Posted: Sat 14 Mar 2020, 19:55
by nic007
What boot loader are you using? Try to boot with pfix=nox parameter. The boot sequence willl stop after the menus and you then type xorgwizard for manual setup and when that is done proceed with the xwin command to start Xorg.

Posted: Sat 14 Mar 2020, 20:10
by 666philb
hi bambuko,

scroll down to bigpups answer here about disabling the nouveau driver (4th post)
http://www.murga-linux.com/puppy/viewtopic.php?p=980928

Posted: Sat 14 Mar 2020, 20:21
by bambuko
@ nic007
I can get to xorgwizard, no problem, but it's no use - it doesn't help me with the driver I need

@ 666philb
that looks promising - thank you for the pointer.
will try it tommorow

Posted: Sun 15 Mar 2020, 00:08
by enrique
If you Desktop have its own monitor port like a VGA or so
Image

Then try to connect your monitor to it. This will allow you to work with your Puppy and install the new driver. Good luck my friend.

Posted: Sun 15 Mar 2020, 11:07
by bambuko
@ enrique
unfortunately your suggestion didn't work - screen remained black despite being connected directly to motherboard rather than GPU

@666philb
tried

Code: Select all

pfix=ram nouveau.modeset=0
didn't work

but....
went back again to xorgwizard to make sure I didn't miss anything and to my surprise option 4) in choose driver:

Code: Select all

fbdev (Framebuffer device based X server)
allowed me to get xwin going

updated Bionicpup updates and downloaded nvidia 440 driver pet

saved things on exit and tried booting again and...

it all behaved as if I didn't save things on exit (i.e. had to start setting country, language, keyboard etc again)
puzzled, but at least it's some progress :)

so then I tried saving things on exit without nvidia 440 driver loaded and guess what - when rebooted country, language and keyboard has been saved OK

so the problem seems to be my inability to install sucessfully invidia 440 driver :? :?: :?:

later edit:
started again (it's easy after all :D ) and this time when doing Bionicpup update I have noticed that (amongst other details) it says:
added nvidia 440 driver ... linuxcbon
so it would appear that there is no need to install this driver separately?
just need to "convince" puppy to use correct driver :?:

and... how do I do it :?: good people, please :D

Posted: Sun 15 Mar 2020, 18:04
by linuxcbon
nvidia 440 driver needs to be installed from quickpet .

Posted: Sun 15 Mar 2020, 18:19
by enrique
I seems to understood you got Xorg working. That is good, first step. I do not have nvidia. So I am just giving you my best suggestion.

Now you need to trobleshout to find out your system. Do:

Code: Select all

lspci -kvnn | grep VGA -A 14
dmesg | grep firmware
The first will tell you your Graphic Adapters details. In particular your drives been used.
The second the firmware your Puppy is been loaded. I thing you need to search for Ubuntus package

Code: Select all

nouveau-firmware
Use your PPM and install that one if that is the case. Then reboot and do again

Code: Select all

dmesg | grep firmware
See if that helps. Do not forget that once your Nvidia Adapter is working you need to plug your monitor to it. Hopes it helps.

Posted: Sun 15 Mar 2020, 18:36
by bambuko
thank you linuxcbon
downloaded nvidia 440, no problem, but...
nvidia-440.36_K4.19.23_x86_64.pet failed to install
later edit:
it was only when I tried to download it from PPM that I got the warning about memory size... (quickpet gave no reason for failure)
resized, downloaded and installed correct (nvidia 440) driver
rebooted and exited to prompt, run xorgwizard and set driver to nvidia 440

SUCCESS :!: :D

Posted: Sun 15 Mar 2020, 18:45
by bambuko
thank you enrique,
at the moment puppy seems to be using integrated CPU controller, rather than GPU
as for nouveau firmware, that's precisely what I do not want (plenty of nvidia driver threads about this on the forum)
at the moment monitor is connected to GPU.

Posted: Sun 15 Mar 2020, 19:22
by linuxcbon
Try from a fresh bionicpup , without any savefile, and from a usb stick.
Update bionic and install nvidia drivers.
Tell us what happens.

Posted: Sun 15 Mar 2020, 19:29
by bambuko
I edited my earlier post, but it's worth repeating :oops:

exited to prompt
run xorgwizard
set driver to nvidia 440

and it is perfect :!: :!:
SOLVED
thank you all who helped :!: